Consumer reporting interfaces have more fun
By Zach Gemignani
May 30, 2006
Find more about:
analytics
Open up your CRM reporting tool. If it looks anything like the tools I've seen, it's all about filters and metrics and bland line graphs. Now imagine it worked a little more like the new Google Finance dashboard:
or like the Baby Name Wizard:
or had an interface like News Map by Marumushi:
Why is it that consumer data visualization tools are so much cleaner, easier to understand, more polished, and engaging than enterprise reporting/analysis tools? I have a few theories:
- Reporting comes last. Reporting is typically the last thing considered and created in development projects. Visibility into the data becomes less important that ensuring data entry, integrity, management, and access. Alternatively, it is a matter of the developers playing to their strengths. Design and data visualization clearly aren't passions - or they'd be unable to launch with these tools.
- Reporting trumps analysis. There is too much emphasis on delivering raw numbers, and not enough emphasis on presenting information in ways that allow users to understand what is going on. Put another way: success is defined as delivering accurate data filtered as the user has defined it. What if success was about delivering new insights about what's going on in the enterprise?
- Comprehensiveness is king. I can just imagine the list of requirements stacked on the desk of the team tasked to build the reporting interface. It's a long list and shoehorning all of it into an interface is hard. The irony is, from what I've seen, really useful data views are left out (like time series and animation).
The examples above offer smooth-animation, mouse-over discovery and highlighting, and a consistent color palette. The baby name explorer and NewsMap are also specific tools that address one specific need very well.








6 comments | Show all comments only the last 5 are shown
EricB said:
Nice call Zach. Classic software can be so inefficient to use! It does seem like we're moving toward a time where it's easier to build creative and useful UI's on top of data (and disparate data) via API's and such.
Robbin Steif said:
Ah, if you guys were bridge players, you would know that you should be writing, "Analysis trumps reporting." When something is trump, it is the most important, it can be anything, it is king of the hill. So what you meant was, analysis is always deemed to be more important than reporting (even though it shouldn't be.)
Robbin
beal said:
I would say that two of the three sites are not particularly useful ... the exception is the naming site ... Google and the headline sites don't tell you what you are really looking ... maybe consumers don't care ... I do ... I would suggest that we are in transition ... my company has many crappy and many good reporting tools ... the question is where any one exists today ... keep up the GREAT work ... this site is a 10
Chris said:
Robbin,
What Zach is saying is that in many business intelligence tools, reporting requirements are given precedence over developing tools that help people explore or analyze data. This isn't a great situation.
Beal,
Thanks for the props. We've got plenty more stuff coming. Consumer products are offering more innovation and exploratory flexibility than business products. I think usiness users will gravitate (eventually) to analytics tools that share these characteristics. Cote over at RedMonk braindumped about this in their RedMonk Radio podcasts a while back. Here's the link if you want to listen. http://redmonk.libsyn.com/index.php?post_id=76628#
Jean-Philippe Papillon said:
In my humble opinion, consumer visualizations are simply given more design attention because the number of potential users is large (a thousand is a bare minimum to launch such an effort). In constrat, entreprise reports are read by a handfull of managers every other weeks.
Indirectly it affects the tool makers.
You point elsewhere in this blog that Excel should provide better default values. But what is the immediate incentive for Microsoft with no competition in sight on that market segment?
PS: on the long run, Firefox proved that a product of quality, with attention to details, can make a comeback. OpenOffice anyone?
Coty said:
Love the inclusion of the Baby Name Wizard. I love that thing--and if you had any idea how my wife and I obsessed over baby names, you'd know I spent a lot of time with it.
said:
Add a comment